To the Left and to the Right: Two Truths for Jews

To the Left and to the Right: Two Truths for Jews
© Rabbi Menachem Creditor

Contamination of the Left by extremists (ab)using the term 'intersectionality' to estrange and attack Jews under cover of political Anti-Zionism. Contamination of the Right by extremists using the term "globalists" to isolate and attack Jews under cover of economic conservativism.

To the Right and to the Left, we say 'feh!'

To those in the Jewish community who see wrongness in one camp and run for the other, I offer these two truths, one more inspiring and practical than the other.

A hurtful truth: What political slice of any nation hasn't historically included antisemitism? The alt-right (white supremacists) and the anti-Israel left (Anti-Semites) are tinged/pervaded by lasting and latent Jew hatred that knows no political ideology, that transcends time and model of societal leadership.

A helpful truth: To reject a political posture because of the germs of hatred in humanity is short sighted. Fighting pernicious Jew-hatred within your political tribe is a better approach, and challenges all the various tribes to be their best selves.

My two cents.

Knowing, Losing, & Growing (#VaEira)

Some Dreams End (VaYechi)

Mythic Method: A Rabbinic Comment on Doctor Who, Season 11

Mythic Method: A Rabbinic Comment on Doctor Who, Season 11
(c) Menachem Creditor

The 11th season of Dr. Who on BBC was a lesson in mythic method: Key elements of a journey are required for a myth to remain alive, and too much change not only disrupts the believability of a story, but threatens the integrity of the previous mythic chapters.

The problem with this season: A new face, a new gender, new companion(s), a new sonic screwdriver - each of these details would be a shock to a familiar friend, and together they were a lot to absorb. But, regarding the mythic strata of Dr. Who, a TV show that has often evoked the deepest depths and the highest heights of humanity's potential, those facets of the Doctor's fade in importance. The real issue is one of sacred storytelling. Stand-alone episodes, which defined Season 11, are not a narrative arc, regardless of the important specifics of each.

Rosa Parks deserved to be woven (and amplified!) into the Doctor's future (and our own) much more carefully, even if the episode was brilliant on its own.

Jodie Whitaker is a magnificent actor and a wonderful Doctor. But the plot she inhabited in Doctor Who Series 11 was largely unworthy of the preceding sacred story the new writers and directors inherited.

Said most simply: In order for the past to remain meaningful, it must be brought with nuance and regularity into the present. And that responsibility falls upon the mythmakers who shape the heartbeat of a universe worthy of a future.

Dr Who Fans are believers in kindness and love - and in second chances. So let's bless the writers and show runners that their next attempt at charting the course of the Time Lord from Gallifrey reflects everything her ancient soul has learned.

Resources on Antisemitism - Faith in Public Life Webinar 12/13/2018

Selected Resources on Antisemitism 

Faith in Public Life Webinar 12/13/2018 

Rabbi Menachem Creditor

• Anti Defamation League (ADL) 2017 Audit of Anti-Semitic Incidents - adl.org/resources/reports/2017-audit-of-anti-semitic-incidents
• ADL "Pyramid of Hate" - adl.org/media/12060/download
• CBS (Dec. 9, 2018) - The longest hatred: Anti-Semitism on the rise - cbsnews.com/news/anti-semitism-on-the-rise/
• The past month's US news stories reporting the appearance of Swastikas - tinyurl.com/recentswastikas
• Ha'aretz: 90 Percent of European Jews Say anti-Semitism Getting Worse, EU Report Finds - haaretz.com/world-news/europe/.premium-90-percent-of-european-jews-say-anti-semitism-getting-worse-eu-report-finds-1.6728980
• The Times of Israel "Anti-Semitism" section - timesofisrael.com/topic/anti-semitism-in-the-us/

What Light Creates

Whispered words, Divine Dreams (Miketz)