Conservative/Masorti Letter to President Obama regarding the UN Security Council Resolution
On Friday ten organizations of the Conservative Movement sent a letter to President Barack Obama in favor of a US Veto of UN Security Council Resolution on Israel and Settlement Activity. It calls for the US to veto any Security Council Resolution condemning Israel over settlement activity in territories east of the "Green Line." The letter reads in part, "As a religious Jewish community, Conservative Jews support Israel as the Jewish state and answer for the legitimate national aspirations of the Jewish people. We look forward to the day when a Palestinian state will be established to answer the legitimate national aspirations of the Palestinian people. We recognize that just as our father Abraham had two sons, Isaac and Ishmael, their descendants - the Jews and the Palestinians - both have a claim on their ancestor's patrimony."
February 3, 2011 – 29 Shvat 5771
The Honorable Barack H. Obama
Dear Mr. President:
The organizations listed below that represent the over 1 million members affiliating with the Conservative Movement in Judaism in the United States, urge your administration and its representatives at the United Nations to veto any resolution introduced with the sole purpose to condemn the State of Israel over the issue of settlement activity in the disputed territories east of the 1948 "Green Line" (the ceasefire line) that were captured by Israel in the 1967 Six Day War.
As UN resolutions 242 and 338 note, it is Israel's responsibility to withdraw from territories (not the territories) taken in 1967. Already the Israeli government has changed policies to limit all building to established communities in the disputed territories and not to initiative building in new areas. However, the depth and extent of withdrawal from the disputed territories to make room for a Palestinian state, is up to the two parties – Israel and the Palestinian representatives – to determine through direct bilateral negotiations. We believe that; we know your administration and those preceding your presidency agree.
As a religious Jewish community, Conservative Jews support Israel as the Jewish state and answer for the legitimate national aspirations of the Jewish people. We look forward to the day when a Palestinian state will be established to answer the legitimate national aspirations of the Palestinian people. We recognize that just as our father Abraham had two sons, Isaac and Ishmael, their descendants – the Jews and the Palestinians – both have a claim on their ancestor's patrimony.
The Palestinian initiative at the United Nations aims to circumvent the obligation for direct bilateral negotiations with Israel. It continues President Abbas' policy to avoid, rather than engage with, Israel. Prime Minister Netanyahu froze such settlement activity for a number of months last year in a good faith effort to restart the peace negotiations. Sadly, the Palestinian Authority decided not to re-engage and continues not to re-engage. American support for a UN condemnation of Israel at this time would only reward the Palestinians for their refusal to negotiate directly with Israel and would do nothing to promote the peace process or move that process forward.
Cantors Assembly – Hazzan David Propis, President & Hazzan Stephen J. Stein, Executive Vice President
Federation of Jewish Men's Clubs – Mark L. Berlin, President & Rabbi Charles Simon, Executive Director
Jewish Educators Assembly – Hedda S. Morton, President & Edward Edelstein, Executive Director
MERCAZ Olami – Dr. Stephen S. Wolnek, President & Rabbi Tzvi Graetz, Executive Director
MERCAZ USA – Janet Tobin, President & Rabbi Robert R. Golub, Executive Director
North American Association of Synagogue Executives (NAASE) – Gilbert Kleiner, President & Harry Hauser, Executive Director
Rabbinical Assembly – Rabbi Gilah Dror, President & Rabbi Julie Schonfeld, Executive Vice President
Schechter Institute of Jewish Studies – Saul Sanders, Chairman & Rabbi David Golinkin, President
United Synagogue of Conservative Judaism – Richard Skolnik, President & Rabbi Steven Wernick, CEO and Executive Vice President
Women's League for Conservative Judaism – Rita Wertlieb, President & Sarrae G. Crane, Executive Director
Rabbi Menachem Creditor
Congregation Netivot Shalom || Bay Area Masorti || ShefaNetwork.org