Feb 7, 2012

Yizhar Hess, CEO of the Masorti Movement (in ynet): "Israel’s Orthodox monopoly has changed from unpleasant annoyance to strategic threat"

America's Jews are worried

Op-ed: Israel's Orthodox monopoly has changed from unpleasant annoyance to strategic threat

Yizhar Hess, CEO of the Masorti Movement

Published:  02.08.12, 00:08 / Israel Opinion

Last week, a contingent of leaders from the North American Conservative movement returned to the US. All the members of this mission, rabbis, congregation leaders and philanthropists, had already been to Israel dozens of times. They are major activists in Jewish Federations, AIPAC, Hadassah, you name it. They didn't come as tourists; they came to ask what has happened, but mainly, what will be?

 

The Jewish population of North America is worried. In recent years Israel, the Jewish state, has put on a large mask with blinders; a mask adorned with a long thick beard, showing the face of creeping fundamentalism. These North American leaders continue to receive emotional requests from organizations in Israel seeking to enlist their political support, or their capital, but they, too, cannot help but ask: where is the money going?

Jewish State
The challenge of haredim /Donniel Hartman
Op-ed: Source of haredi power and influence lies in failure of mainstream Israeli society
Full Story

 

How can it be that a soldier receives NIS 360-700 a month, while a yeshiva student gets NIS 900? How can a country whose civil bodies are constantly raising funds for the education system allow regular state school classrooms to have an average of 28 students (if only my daughter Mika's class of 39 students would be reduced to this average, but an average is an average); whereas an ultra-Orthodox pupil has an average of 20 children in his class?

 

And in general, why did funding for the ultra-Orthodox education system rise so sharply, by almost 50%, in a three-year period (2006-2009), way-way more than their natural growth in the population?

 

These Jewish community leaders are also asking, with ever-increasing determination, what the State of Israel thinks about them, the Jews of North America.

 

They met with ministers, Knesset members, mayors, with the outgoing head of the Mossad, and with the US Ambassador to Israel. One of the heads of this mission, the former chairperson of a Conservative congregation of 1,400 families, spoke of the way she teaches her children to love Israel, about the prayer for the welfare of the state of Israel recited every Shabbat in her synagogue, about the Israeli songs, and the Hebrew slang that they use whenever they can.

 

2nd class Jews? 

She also talked about her deep fear that her son, who will shortly be coming for an entire year on one of the programs for Jewish youth, will fall in love with an Israeli. She knows that they will not be able to marry here. "I'm a Jew By Choice; I was converted in a Conservative conversion many years ago," she said her eyes wet with tears. "The practices and policies of the Jewish state turn me and my children into second class Jews."

 

Some of the people they met admitted unequivocally – although they did not want to be quoted – that the Orthodox monopoly in Israel has long since changed from an unpleasant annoyance to a strategic threat to the strength of the State of Israel, both because of its growing impact on relations between the Jews of the Diaspora and Israel, and because of the alienation of hundreds of thousands of Israelis, including many who are not halakhically Jewish, and for whom the Orthodox establishment, in all of its variations, has managed to make Judaism odious.

 

Those who hold Israel dear to their hearts, who check the news several times a day on the leading English language sites, and who anxiously follow the changes taking place in Israeli society, are extremely disturbed by the Jewish fundamentalism, chauvinism, and legislation that exudes an anti-democratic spirit, unprecedented in any previous Knesset.

 

"The Jews of America must courageously rethink the way in which they invest in Israel," one of the heads of this mission concluded.

 

A Conservative rabbi, one of the most influential in North America today, said "we must create a new kashrut certificate, a kashrut certification for social projects. Projects that do not reinforce democracy in Israel should be crossed off our list. Those programs that contribute to democracy should remain. They will receive a "kashrut" certificate. The projects and programs that directly encourage democratic values, and emphasize Jewish pluralism, will be placed at the head of our list. They will receive a mehadrin kashrut certificate. Israel is too precious for us to remain indifferent."

 

Yizhar Hess is the Executive Director & CEO of the Masorti Movement in Israel


---
Rabbi Menachem Creditor
To join Rabbi Creditor's email list, send a blank email to thetisch-subscribe@yahoogroups.com.
Check out my new album, "Within" on itunes!

JFSJ + PJA = SUPPORT THE HOME CARE WORKFORCE NOW!

jfsj_logo.gif

I just added my signature. Will you? -- "America's 1.7 million home care workers stand on the threshold of earning the same federal labor protections that most workers take for granted – and just five minutes of your time can make the difference. On December 15, 2011 President Obama proposed a rule change that, if approved, will finally provide some measure of justice to home care workers who have long been exempted from minimum wage and overtime laws. Right now the U.S. Department of Labor is accepting public comments on the proposed change, which would correct part of a longstanding legacy of devaluing the work of women and African Americans." -  http://www.jewishjustice.org/expand-fair-labor-protections-home-care-workers 


---
Rabbi Menachem Creditor
To join Rabbi Creditor's email list, send a blank email to thetisch-subscribe@yahoogroups.com.
Check out my new album, "Within" on itunes!

Feb 6, 2012

a great blurb from a great leadership article

"Boards that foster a culture of inquiry," [Nancy Axelrod] writes, "are better positioned to tackle controversial matters, to look at issues from all sides, and make thoughtful decisions. When dialogue, candor, and dissent are all part of group dynamics, board members master the skills of learning, dissecting the issues, and responding thoughtfully, truthfully, and in the best interests of the organization."  --  http://exceptionalboards.com/2012/02/06/reversal-of-fortune/ 

---
Rabbi Menachem Creditor
To join Rabbi Creditor's email list, send a blank email to thetisch-subscribe@yahoogroups.com.
Check out my new album, "Within" on itunes!

Feb 3, 2012

Chancellor Eisen on Huffpost: "Moses, Pharaoh and the Candidates"

Chancellor Arnold M. Eisen: "Moses, Pharaoh and the Candidates"
The Jewish Theological Seminary
Posted: 02/ 2/2012 2:02 pm
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/arnold-m-eisen/moses-pharaoh-and-the-presidential-candidates_b_1246898.html

Two very different leadership contests have competed for the attention of religiously observant American Jews in recent weeks. One of them played out among Republican candidates seeking the right to challenge Barack Obama for leadership of the most powerful nation on earth. The other played out in the Torah portions describing the fateful battle in the name of the Lord that Moses conducted against Pharaoh, in his day the most powerful ruler on earth. I couldn't help looking at each contest in the light of the other, despite real reluctance to sully the Exodus narrative -- one of the most profound and sacred stories in the biblical canon -- by comparing it to a political campaign that has lately been the opposite of noble. The juxtaposition proved too illuminating to ignore.


Note first what the Bible has to say to the questions on many American minds as the mudslinging and counterpunching take their toll week by week on candidates and electorate alike: Why would anyone in their right mind want to go through this? Why would any sane person seek the presidency? Moses, notably, did not seek his prophetic office; indeed, he begged God to send someone else to stand before the Israelites and Pharaoh. Unlike candidates who proclaim that they alone are worthy of our vote, Moses repeatedly and quite sincerely professed his lack of suitability for the task of leading the Israelites. He is the first in a line of prophets who established a rule that holds good for many biblical leaders: if you want the job, you're not right for it. God does not choose individuals who approach with confidence the difficulties that await them (not least the difficulty of standing before God and doing God's bidding). One wishes that candidates for modern elected office had similar humility -- and that the public were wise enough to reward that virtue rather than scorning it.

Pharaoh, for his part, is not equipped to do anything but say no. He is schooled for power and only for power and, as a result, is ill-equipped to imagine any options beyond a narrow repertoire of intimidation, manipulation and control. It is difficult to blame the king for not knowing the new god in whose name Moses demands liberation of the Israelites. One is not surprised that Pharaoh's first reaction to the plagues God rains on Egypt is to ignore them, his second is to try to use the new god rather than obey him, and his third is to negotiate. Offer your sacrifices here in Egypt, Pharaoh tells Moses at one point: The men can go, perhaps, but not the women or children. By the ninth plague of the 10, however, it seems that Pharaoh has been trapped by the limits of his own political imagination. "Remove this death from me," he begs in a moment of honest weakness, only to stand fast again and refuse to think about reengineering his economy to do without slave labor. "Go -- but leave your flocks," he proposes as Egypt sinks into darkness. Only the 10th plague changes his mind, and that change too proves temporary. He will not let the slave-people go. He would rather die.

The lesson for world leaders battling historical forces of similar magnitude seems clear, even if -- this being the Bible -- that lesson is neither simple nor easily put into practice. Moses succeeds as the leader of the Israelites not only because he has God on his side, but because he reaches deep into every pocket of his experience, tests every ounce of his resilience, and stretches the horizon of his mind past anything he or anyone else has previously encountered. He will soon learn that standing for God and before God often requires him to stand up to God in defense of the people. The Israelites disappoint him, infuriate him, mock his leadership and -- once out of Egypt -- display little faith that the God who got them across the sea will bring them to the Promised Land. Yet Moses refuses to give up on them, and will not let God give up on them either. Moses exhibits a sort of integrity -- personal and national -- that is rarely found in any leader, ancient or contemporary. He is one with himself and one with his people, loving them despite their failures and refusing to accede to those failures, because he knows his people can do better.

The comparison between Moses and present-day leaders or candidates breaks down a bit (though not entirely) in at least two respects. Readers of the Bible of course know that Moses had God behind him (though it is worth remembering that Moses's contemporaries, including members of his own Levitic clan, were sometimes not so sure). What is more, Moses is a wartime, rather than a peacetime, leader. His job is to take charge of a violent uprising that leaves no Egyptian household untouched by death. The rebellion succeeds, launching a prolonged phase of wilderness wandering, only after Pharaoh's army drowns in the sea.

I think Moses realizes early on that his upbringing at court conferred the indispensable ability to take on the Pharaoh, but it was his murder of the Egyptian taskmaster (Exodus 2:12) that qualified him to stand alongside God as the leader of a revolution. His own resort to violence made Moses complicit in the violence that God, with his assistance, will wreak on Egypt. For the same reason, I suspect, God's announcement to Moses that every firstborn male in Egypt will die is followed without pause in the text by the mysterious passage in which God appears to attack Moses's own firstborn son, who is saved only when the boy's mother suddenly circumcises him with a piece of flint (Exodus 4:25). Moses needs to learn the terror of violence, and its impact on victim as well as perpetrator, before he makes violence his instrument and, by doing so, becomes its instrument.

Every American president in our time has borne this burden too. The weighty responsibility for war seems utterly out of keeping with the tenor of campaign rhetoric, unless one believes that dishing out insults and withstanding them in turn is a kind of proxy -- like football -- for battering the enemy and shouldering the burden of American casualties.

I am struck by one final relevant juxtaposition as I write this essay on the eve of the Florida primary. Moses learns near the very beginning of his career as a leader that he cannot lead the Israelites to freedom without sacrificing popularity. This is, of course, the difference between divine election and democracy, and it causes one to wonder how and whether a future (or current) leader can tell people what they need to hear -- the very definition of true leadership -- rather than succumbing to the apparent political necessity of telling them what they want to hear.

Moses's life seems to grow harder rather than easier with every achievement he records, every challenge he meets, every step he takes with his people on the circuitous journey toward the Promised Land. Allies -- even his own brother -- prove unreliable. God, by the end, has become his best friend, perhaps his only friend.

Why take on such a task? Because you know you are called; know that with help you can do it; and know that, when the task seems impossible, God, your spouse, your friends and perhaps history will lend a hand.

---
Rabbi Menachem Creditor
To join Rabbi Creditor's email list, send a blank email to thetisch-subscribe@yahoogroups.com.
Check out my new album, "Within" on itunes!

Feb 2, 2012

Feb 26th at 1pm: A Learning Celebration in honor of the publication of "Paths of Torah!"

Save the Date! 
A Learning Celebration in honor of the publication of "Paths of Torah!"
Sunday, Feb 26th at 1pm
Congregation Netivot Shalom

Paths_jacket_111711_FINAL.png

After 3 years of sacred work by over 60 members of Congregation Netivot Shalom, the book "Paths of Torah" was published this month! "Paths of Torah", a professionally edited collection of shul members' Divrei Torah over twenty years. The book reflects the diversity of one Jewish community's ongoing relationship with Torah. It is an unfinished record of an ongoing, cross-generational dream. In the pages of our new treasure, readers will find heirlooms, stories, struggles and dreams, and most important, an invitation to continue the dialogue with Torah.  At this celebration, Torah learning will be facilitated by some contributors to the book, coffee, light refreshments, and childcare will be provided. 

Purchase your copy of "Paths of Torah" at the event, at Netivot Shalom during office hours, 
at Afikomen Judaica, or through EKS online at ekspublishing.com!

---
Rabbi Menachem Creditor
To join Rabbi Creditor's email list, send a blank email to thetisch-subscribe@yahoogroups.com.
Check out my new album, "Within" on itunes!

Feb 1, 2012

Beshalach 5772: "Turning"

Beshalach 5772: "Turning"
(c) Rabbi Menachem Creditor
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jfGZ8YLIO9o



---
Rabbi Menachem Creditor
To join Rabbi Creditor's email list, send a blank email to thetisch-subscribe@yahoogroups.com.
Check out my new album, "Within" on itunes!

I Support Planned Parenthood's Fund for Breast Cancer Services

6a01347fb7eafb970c014e896d7e01970d-250wi
I'm shifting my tezedakah giving. You can too. read here: ""Alarmed and Saddened" by Komen Foundation Succumbing to Political Pressure, Planned Parenthood Launches Fund for Breast Cancer Services" -- http://www.plannedparenthood.org/about-us/newsroom/press-releases/alarmed-saddened-komen-foundation-succumbing-political-pressure-planned-parenthood-launches-fun-38629.htm

---
Rabbi Menachem Creditor
To join Rabbi Creditor's email list, send a blank email to thetisch-subscribe@yahoogroups.com.
Check out my new album, "Within" on itunes!

Total Pageviews